RSS

Glass vs. Tupperware

12 Nov

ecobezhig

This should spark off a brawl in the NSW Seakayaking Club also known as the Mirage Appreciation Society! I am going to assert here that plastic tupperware boats are better than glass. Actually, I’m not, as I will be buying a glass boat next. What I going  amto contend is that glass boats do not have an automatic assumption of superiority. Glass, rather composite, boat afficianados believe their boats are faster, stiffer, lighter and more “serious” a boat. There is an underlying belief that plastic boats are toylike and for beginners. There maybe some elements of truth in these but let’s look at this in reality. They are not faster! In fact without a paddler they are completely motionless. The assumption of higher speed is virtually unprovable. I am 110kg, an ex weight lifter and competitive swimmer. Though 44 years old and in poor shape I am physically powerful and over a short distance can out paddle most. In my Ecobezhig I could easily outpace most club paddlers over say 500m.

My boat is 5.4m and goes like a rocket when I’m in a good cadence. Let’s say I go up against a similar person in a Mirage 580. Now the Miraganista could argue a strong case for better hydrodynamic design and a host of other technical advantages. I would even believe it. But the only way to determine which boat has intrinsic speed advantages would be to test each boat with the same paddler in the the same completely still stretch of water with no wind and over many repeated runs with the paddler rested and in the same energy state each time. Pretty bloody impossible I’d say. The reality is that even taking the boat off the roof of the car creates a real-world variation that affects speed. Each wave, each swell, each gust and miss-stroke, each look to the left and right, a bad night’s sleep, breakfast, all add up to paddler variables that completely swamp any technical edge in the boat. If the Mirage has a 10% technical edge over my Eco and I have a 12% edge over the Mirage paddler, I’m faster.

This also relates to stiffness. Big deal. So my boat bends a bit and warps. I’ve read enough hydrodynamic review to know that stiff is not a real advantage. It’s a point of view. You can take 10 boat designers and get 10 different ideas about designing speed. Whichever one you take is just an opinion.

The better built argument is the easiest to debunk. Rock launching and landing is a no brainer win to plastic. Though I have been paddling for years, relative to my club I’m a noobie. I am more likely to screw up, smash the boat up, drop it or whatever. Do this on composite and spend the night patching it up. I wash mine down and put it away. Of course, it’s easier to repair composite but this just confirms my point. You have to. Arguing that a good paddler shouldn’t bust their boat is a non-argument. Of course, they shouldn’t but that’s got nothing to do with the boat. Paddler superiority is another argument.

Composite boats are not lighter either. The Ecobezhig is 24kg. The same as a Mirage. End of argument. You see most of the arguments stem from a confusion with kayaks versus the kayak/paddler combination. At the moment, for all the reasons above, plastics boats for me are superior. The advantages they offer are being deployed, now. My EcoBezhig is fantastic because it’s light, reliable, fast and very comfortable. That said my next boat will be either a Mirage 580 or a Nadgee, depending on the best fit, best service and best deal.

Advertisements
 
5 Comments

Posted by on November 12, 2007 in About Kayaks

 

Tags: , , , ,

5 responses to “Glass vs. Tupperware

  1. Douglas

    November 14, 2007 at 10:19 pm

    Hello Brad you make some very good points about the comparison of poly and composite boats. I have a composite Nordkapp LV but managed to borrow a poly Nordkapp RM for three months. I enjoyed it very much. The poly boat compared very similarly to my friend’s composite Nordkapp’s performance but had all the advantages of robustness.

    :o)

     
  2. rjimlad

    November 15, 2007 at 8:41 am

    I posted this to get some feedback from my net challenged club as its a contentious issue for some. I love the look of Nordkapps but we don’t see many here. You won’t see many Ecobezhigs in Scotland either as they’re a kiwi boat and well suited to Oz conditions.

     
  3. Danny Morgan

    November 23, 2007 at 9:43 pm

    Hi Brad,
    Thankyou for the e.mail , I might get out on the sea on Sunday finger’s crossed if the wind’s ease ,No 40 deg C here mate, only 2 deg c at this moment in time and definitely no fly’s , and trust me the ocean feel’s colder , you go in a man and come out a boy, my work mate is moving your way to live( Pacific Height’s near Brisbane )if my spelling’s correct,he was showing me the spending money note’s 20’s and 50’s who’s the guy with the bi-plane?keep in touch and keep up the blog all the best and keep it safe Danny Northern Ireland..

     
  4. rjimlad

    November 24, 2007 at 12:21 pm

    You need a magnifying glass but most of our notes have stories written on them. One note has “The Man from Snowy River” on it. We have interesting and waterproof money.

     
  5. Mark Sundin

    December 9, 2007 at 8:35 pm

    Fear not guys, from January 10, there will be the famous Valley Nordkapps, Aqauanauts, Aquanaut HV & Avocents avaialble in Australia, in the best made polyethylene known to man. The specs are at http://www.expeditionkayaks.com

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: